Four hundred dollars.
That’s what Bruce Abramski’s uncle sent him to buy a Glock 19. Abramski was a former police officer, he had the law-enforcement discount, and his uncle Angel Alvarez was a man who could legally own a handgun — no record, no prohibition, nothing. Uncle wires the money, nephew buys the gun with the discount, nephew hands it over through a dealer in his uncle’s state. Everybody’s clean on paper.
The Supreme Court said no. Five to four, 2014, Justice Kagan writing. Abramski lied on his 4473 when he checked the box saying he was the actual buyer, and it didn’t matter one bit that his uncle could have walked into any shop in Pennsylvania and bought the same pistol himself.
Keep that in your pocket for the next five weeks, because gun counters between now and Christmas fill up with people buying for somebody else.
Here’s the part that trips good people up: buying a gun as a gift is perfectly legal. Always has been. The 4473’s own instructions say so in plain language — if you walk in, pick out a shotgun with your own money, and put it under the tree for your son, you ARE the actual buyer. You bought it. You decided on it. Then you gave away a thing you owned. That’s a gift, and the government has never had a problem with it.
What the government has a problem with is the money and the decision moving the other way.
So the line isn’t “who ends up with the gun.” The line is “whose purchase was this.” Your wife mentions she likes the Ruger, you go buy the Ruger, you wrap the Ruger — fine. Your wife hands you six hundred bucks and the stock number and says pick this up for me — that’s her purchase with your name on the form, and the form asks you a direct question about exactly that.
That’s it. That’s the whole distinction, and it survives every version of this conversation I’ve had across a counter.
Two things will get you in trouble faster than the paperwork, though.
The first is who you’re handing it to. You cannot gift a firearm to somebody who can’t legally have one, and the statute doesn’t require that you knew for a fact — “reasonable cause to believe” is enough to make it a federal felony. Which means the cousin with the domestic conviction, the nephew everybody in the family quietly worries about, the brother-in-law in the middle of a bad divorce with a protective order against him: that’s not a gift, that’s a case. If a little voice is asking the question, the little voice is the answer.
The second is state lines, in both senses.
You can’t hand a gun directly to somebody who lives in another state. Not a handgun, not a rifle, not as a gift, not ever — it goes to a dealer in their state and they do the paperwork there. The feds don’t care that it’s your own daughter. And inside your own state, a dozen-plus states now require every transfer to run through an FFL with a background check, family included, though most of those carve out some version of an immediate-family exemption. Some of those exemptions cover a gift to your kid. Some cover handguns only. California wants a form filed. The exemption you’re thinking of is probably real and probably narrower than you remember, so look up your own state before you wrap anything.
The clean move, if any of this makes your neck itch, is a gift certificate. Dealer sells it, recipient comes in, recipient fills out their own 4473 and passes their own check. ATF has blessed that one for years. It’s less fun to hand somebody an envelope than a rifle case, and it’s a lot less fun to explain a felony to your wife.
Congress made this heavier in 2022, by the way. Straw purchasing used to get charged as a false statement on a form. Now it’s its own federal crime with its own section of the code and up to fifteen years behind it.
Fifteen years, for a man who bought a pistol his uncle could have legally bought himself, because the four hundred dollars moved in the wrong direction first.
Buy the gun. Pay for it yourself. Make sure the person opening it isn’t somebody a judge has told no. If they live out of state, call a dealer where they live.
And if your brother hands you cash and a stock number, hand it back and tell him you’ll drive him down there Saturday.